Showing posts with label Trophy repair. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trophy repair. Show all posts

Saturday, October 31, 2026

3D Printed Trophy Repair V2.0

 

Challenge/Background: This is the alternate version of the project that was featured yesterday.   In this option, which is the other student designed version that we are looking at as a potential solution to the problem that was posed to our students.

This option is significantly smaller than yesterdays version.   Again to repeat was stated we are looking at replacing the broken top piece.

These are the final test prints for this project which we are intending to look at prior to a print with increased infill and then apply spray paint for the finish.

Resources used to complete the print were the same as yesterday.   

Size: This version of the print measures 30mm across and the front and is 70mm high.   The print has a width of 25mm.

Cost/Price: The print used 5.5g of PLA, regular Bambu Cotton Candy PLA.   This had a price point of $0.11 which meant it was extremely inexpensive to produce.

Timeframe: The print took twenty nine minutes to complete the print.   The printer has a warm up time and set up time of six minutes meaning the full print time was twenty two minutes.   If the print has a subsequent increase to its infill then there would expected to be an increase in these figures.

What we would do differently/Next steps for the students:

When the design was placed on the trophy as shown left it appeared to meet the size requirements but ultimately the decision will be made by the school as the most appropriate for the trophy.   The question of reinforcing this design and increasing the size of the base to make more of wedge shape.

Once we have completed the design we will update this post.

Friday, October 30, 2026

3D Printed Trophy Repair


Challenge: To repair a broken school trophy authentically with the 3D Printer for a presentation award.

Background: We've had two previous attempts at this project.  The first attempt in August was from a virtual perspective when we didn't complete a design rather we took the first steps towards designing a solution.

In the second version, also published in August we looked at a further refinement of the design where we made an attempt to create something realistic.

The audience for this project was important - although we had a number of students start the project we were ultimately looking for a single print but one that could be mounted on the trophy, which is currently over thirty years old.   It is due to be presented at our school prize giving at the end of this year.   Despite appearances the trophy is essentially plastic.   We have spent time looking at trying to create various Netball themed trophy toppers and have reached the conclusion that using a smaller trophy would likely give the best results.   The two final designs are featured in this print.  

This is the first in its final test phase.  It has been created using the Tinkercad template trophy design.  To support it at the base a wedge has been developed that matches the base of the design.  While it has been printed in pink its final design will be spray painted metallic and we will look at increasing the density of the print, which is currently based on the default.

The design was completed in under ten minutes by two students working together to complete the project.   They did not require any teacher input.

Resources to complete this print: iPad, School Trophy (for dimensions), Tinkercad App, Tinkercad, Bambu P1S Printer, Bambu PLA (regular Cotton Candy).

Size: The print can be measured in two distinct parts.  The wedge at the base is 80mm across 30mm long on the sides and 40mm wide at the back.  It has a height of 20mm.   The trophy itself is 70mm high and 80mm wide including the handles.   This size is dictated by the desire to have the trophy sitting 'flush' on the top of the trophy base.

Cost/Price: This print uses 30g of PLA to complete the print, which includes two trees either side of the design to hold the handle in place.  Based on this use of PLA the project has a price point of $0.60c.

Once the design was completed and the likely price was determined we also experimented with projecting the design onto the base as shown above top left.  This gave us a clear idea of what the design would look like, as it was shown left with the physical print put in place and then placed in position on the trophy base.

Also of note at this point - we discovered that while this is a Netball trophy the ball in the top right hand front of the design, which is the actual original design for the trophy is a basketball!

Timeframe: To complete this print the printer was operating for one hour and eight minutes, including a six minute warm up time.

What we would do differently/Next steps for the students: In this instance the students want to check with the school to ensure that the trophy meets expectations.  Once this has been sprayed metallic we should have two clear choices that will be available and then we will look at gluing the new top into place.   We also will have the advantage of having the original design so we will be able to reprint it as required if there was to be any additional damage or issues with the trophy.


Monday, August 10, 2026

Physical Trophy Repair: Junior 3D Print

 

Challenge: To repair a thirty year old school trophy. 

Background: This print project was detailed on this blog last week - you can click on the link to the post about the planning and the virtual creation of variations here.  

As we stated we were making it possible for all of the students to have input into the design but the printing of physical trophy tops was going to be limited to prints that would be extremely close as we needed essentially just one.

The first print to meet this criteria is detailed in this post here.  The student used the Netball that they were able to find online as a key element as well a generic star and hoop.   The final part was the 'Netball' heading although this is going to be refined.

Resources used to complete this print: The student used their iPad, the Tinkercad App, the Bambu H2D and regular Blue PLA.

Level of Difficulty: Medium - this in some ways is one of those simple projects that needs to be done really, really well which increases its difficulty.  Its about a thirty year old trophy and it needs to be fitting with the style, purpose and quality of the original.   No easy feat.

Size: This print is currently coming in with dimensions of  60mm across the font a width of 60mm and a height of 80mm.  This will need adjustment for the final print (see the photograph below) the mounting is currently two big for the base that it needs to be mounted on.

Cost/Price: The print at the moment has a usage of 28g of PLA and this has a price point of $0.57c.   This print is being reimagined (see below) so this is going to be adjusted.

Timeframe: The print as it stands took one hour and thirty five minutes to complete.  (see below).

What we would do differently/Next steps for the students: When the 3D Print is applied to the existing trophy it is clear that adjustments need to be made.   The base of the print needs to be adjusted so that it meets the contours of the existing trophy (instead of overlapping).   

The print itself is currently using a default infill (of twenty percent) for the final version of the print this is going to be increased to give the print more weight but also crucially make it more robust.   

The inscription at the moment is currently too generic.  It needs to be specific for the trophy.

The colour of the print needs to be located as a spray paint.   The pieces that are broken despite the appearance is plastic.

Finally the entire process needs to be checked and approved by the senior management of the school as this is something that we are intending to last for as long as possible.

Wednesday, August 5, 2026

3D Printed Prize Giving Trophy Repair

 

Challenge: To repair a thirty year old school trophy.

Background: We are always looking for opportunities to have our students solve problems or involve themselves in practical related activities - such in this instance this trophy.

The trophy is awarded in the sport of Netball - the trophy has an engagement plate on the back which has been awarded for thirty years.   Despite its sheen and appearance the figure that is on the top of the trophy is plastic - which has had a coating applied to it to make it appear different.   When examined in detail it has been repaired at the base of the players feet already several times.

Netball in itself produces a challenge - Netball is something of a niche sport.   We have been searching for a Netball figure that is available as an .stl file and are currently unable to locate one.   This has meant that the students have experimented with using other figures or concentrating on really generic figures.   We are specifically looking at mounting something on the top of the trophy in the middle, at the highest point.   As a classroom challenge this is something the whole class could easily get involved with.   While the output of the project is a single print.

The montage left shows a design that has then been AR/VR into place using the Tinkercad App (this feature is available to iPad users, not browser users of the Tinkercad online page.

The design left was created by a pair of nine year olds from our classroom in one ten minutes session.  Once they had completed the basic design they then took the original trophy and experimented with background so they could successfully AR/VR the design.

The filers from Pic Collage were then applied to a screenshot from the Tinkercad AR/VR to show the different affects that might be possible with the design.   Not all of the filters were successful as some have a tendency to overwhelm the designs.   The next step with the process for the entire class is to refine their original designs.

The audience for this task is exceedingly important.  We have created a range of trophies in the past.  This year we have already created various trophies and awards and we also have last years exemplar masterclass project which is available to be viewed here.

In the design left students worked on something that looked like it might fit based on size and then once this proved viable or not were intending to expand the process to include more detail.   

The person who commissioned the project is going to review all of the designs and from there select three or four of the designs that they feel meets the brief of the project the best.  Once these have been identified they are going to be printed and then the physical designs will be evaluated and looking at selecting one or two as final projects.  An important aspect of the success of this project is the colour matching - that will be finding a spray painting colour that matches the shine and the appearance of the original design.